Files
agent-estate-wiki/incidents/2026-11-09-stocktake-completes-with-zero-edits.md
T

66 lines
4.8 KiB
Markdown

---
title: "2026-11-09 — Stocktake Completes With Zero Edits"
type: incident
status: active
created: 2026-11-10
updated: 2026-11-10
verified_on: 2026-11-10
confidence: high
tags: [cron, wiki, stocktake, tool-budget, silent-failure, omni-101, free-stack]
sources: ["executions.db (1a8e90ea2271: 2026-11-09T03:00:43+08:00 → 2026-11-09T12:10:47+08:00, status completed, delivery_outcome suppressed)", "~/.hermes/cron/output/1a8e90ea2271/2026-11-09_12-10-46.md (8,305 bytes; RUN INCOMPLETE, \\u201ctool-iteration budget exhausted during verification\\u201d)", "cron_incidents (1a8e90_628d914f1f97, 1a8e90_2f370ef764f5, 1a8e90_a9cad99cb150 — all closed 2026-11-09T12:10:47.125205+08:00)", "wiki-stocktake-maintenance job 1a8e90ea2271 (provider custom:omni-101, model free-stack)"]
---
# 2026-11-09 — Stocktake Completes With Zero Edits
## Summary
The nightly wiki stocktake (`wiki-stocktake-maintenance`, `1a8e90ea2271`) ran on 2026-11-09 from **03:00:43 to 12:10:47** — **9 h 10 m** — and the harness recorded it **`completed`** with delivery `suppressed`. Its own output file records the opposite: the run ran out of tool-iteration budget inside its verification phase, applied **zero edits**, made **no commit**, and its findings never landed.
**This is the third consecutive day the stocktake's work did not land** — 11-07 died at 2 h 02 m, 11-08 at 1 h 35 m (both `failed`), 11-09 at 9 h 10 m (`completed`). The visible status this time is *worse*, not better: `failure_streak` fell **3 → 0** and `last_status` shows **ok**, while the work stayed undone.
## Timeline (AWST, 2026-11-09)
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| 03:00:43 | Run starts (`1a8e90ea2271`) |
| ~04:1x | Tool-iteration budget exhausted during verification; output file written with `RUN INCOMPLETE` |
| 12:10:47.125205 | Harness closes the run — `completed`, delivery `suppressed` |
| 12:10:47.125205 | The **three** long-open stocktake incident rows close at the same instant: `1a8e90_628d914f1f97` (11-07T04:29:54), `1a8e90_2f370ef764f5` (11-07T05:02:21), `1a8e90_a9cad99cb150` (11-08T04:35:38) |
## Root Cause
Same family as 11-07/11-08: **the run spends its entire tool budget before reaching the write phase.** The run's own output file records the stop as the tool-iteration budget being exhausted **during verification**, with zero edits applied — the edits it had identified were never written.
Secondary cause (confirmed again this window): the job is pinned to `custom:omni-101` / **`free-stack`** — a combo recorded broken on **2026-08-14** (see [[systems/scheduled-tasks]]).
## Evidence
- `executions.db`: `started_at 2026-11-09T03:00:43+08:00` → `finished_at 2026-11-09T12:10:47+08:00`, `status completed`, `delivery_outcome suppressed`. Previous two runs: 11-08 `failed` (03:01:11 → 04:36:08, 1 h 35 m), 11-07 `failed` (03:00:31 → 05:02:22, 2 h 02 m).
- Output file `/home/hermes/.hermes/cron/output/1a8e90ea2271/2026-11-09_12-10-46.md` (8,305 bytes) ends `RUN INCOMPLETE`, with the tool-iteration budget exhausted inside verification.
- The three stocktake incident rows all carry `closed_at = 2026-11-09T12:10:47.125205+08:00` — i.e. they closed on **completion**, not on a fix. All three have `alerted_at = null`: they never alerted.
- Git: **no stocktake commit on 11-09** — zero edits were applied, so there was nothing to commit and nothing to revert. (On 11-07/11-08 the page was left dirty and then reverted; on 11-09 no edit was ever made.)
## Impact
- Nine consecutive stalled stocktake runs (11-01 … 11-09) — the nightly wiki freshness pass is producing no durable output.
- The stocktake's *top-priority* brief item on 11-09 was the **monotonically worsening failure streak** itself. The job closed its own incident while failing that item, which is the failure mode to watch: **`completed` and `ok` now overstate the stocktake's health.**
- Three incident rows were silently cleared, so the fleet's incident board now reads **0 open** while the underlying problem is unfixed.
## Fix Applied
**None — this is a detection-and-verification record.** The page documents the failure and the misleading status so the next audit starts from truth.
Also recorded this window: the `free-stack` pin on `1a8e90ea2271` — the only deterministic configuration fault in the chain — is **still in place**, unchanged from the 11-08 record.
## Prevention
- **Alerting must fire on write progress, not completion.** This run produced 2 of 3 failure days silently and the third day produced a run that reported success while editing nothing. A check on `commit_count` / `edits_applied` for this job would have caught all three.
- Don't read `status`/`failure_streak` as the stocktake's health. Read whether a commit landed.
## Related
- [[systems/scheduled-tasks]]
- [[infrastructure/tailscale]]
- [[incidents/2026-11-08-pre-tool-call-hook-timeout-cascade]]
- [[incidents/2026-11-09-job-radar-stage1-stall-silent-noop]]