Files
agent-estate-wiki/incidents/2026-08-15-skills-index-drift.md
Tony0410 2f3fc9952b stocktake 2026-11-05: fix skills-index generator divergence at the root; correct Docker + Tailscale drift against live probes
ROOT CAUSE FIXED - systems/skills-index.md had TWO WRITERS:
the repo wiki-maintain.sh (302 skills / 68 categories) and the stale
~/.hermes/scripts/wiki-maintain.sh (mtime 2026-08-17, 349 skills / 26
categories - it used Path.rglob() and counted the parked .archive/ tree) were
different scripts with different generators, and wiki-maintenance/SKILL.md
line 569 pointed the 23:59 nightly audit at the stale path while the 03:00
stocktake ran the repo path. Each job overwrote the other's page; neither
raised an error. The stale copy is now a delegating wrapper with no generator
logic, and the repo script gained --no-build so the wrapper honours the old
interface without a second generator. Verified by execution.

Live-probe corrections:
- infrastructure/docker-services.md: CT200 61 running / 68 total (was 62);
  worldmonitor-seeder-scheduled does not exist on ANY host (zero 'seeder'
  matches across CT200/201/333/460); CT333 first container renamed again
  (nostalgic_leavitt -> flamboyant_mahavira); CT201 20/26, CT460 1/1,
  CT1001 1/9.
- infrastructure/tailscale.md: node table verified programmatically - 52 rows
  vs 52 live IPv4 peers, no live peer missing, no orphan row, every
  online/offline state matching. conduit 59d->60d, ubuntu-server-xfce
  75d->76d. Serve table still matches tailscale serve status exactly.
- infrastructure/hosts.md: skills figure corrected to 302 / 68 categories.
- index.md: skills-index bullet refreshed to the 2026-11-05 figures.

New incident: incidents/2026-11-05-skills-index-generator-divergence.md
(closes the still-open item on the 2026-08-15 skills-index drift incident).

Freshness: 0 stale / 123 fresh / 3 no-date of 126 pages.
2026-11-05 05:55:45 +08:00

109 lines
6.0 KiB
Markdown

---
title: "Skills Index Drift — 4x Undercount"
type: incident
status: active
created: 2026-08-15
updated: 2026-11-05
resolved_on: 2026-08-15
reopened_on: 2026-10-23
verified_on: 2026-11-05
confidence: high
tags: [skills, wiki, drift, auto-regeneration]
sources: [session-investigation, agent-estate-wiki, live-filesystem-probe, cron-executions-db]
---
# Skills Index Drift — 4x Undercount
## Summary
The `systems/skills-index.md` page in both wikis claimed **66 skills** when **330 were actually installed** — a 4x undercount. The page had been hand-written once on 2026-07-22/25 and never regenerated as the estate grew.
## Root Cause
Static documentation for a mutable inventory. The skills tree at `~/.hermes/skills/` grew from ~66 to 330 skills over three weeks, but the wiki page was never updated because there was no automation to keep it in sync.
## Impact
- Wiki page was 4x out of date
- Any inventory-based decisions (skill loading, capacity planning) would have been based on wrong numbers
- No functional impact — skills still loaded correctly via Tool Search
## Resolution
1. Regenerated `systems/skills-index.md` from the live skill tree (all 330 skills, 26 categories)
2. Created a regeneration script for automated regeneration — **superseded on 2026-10-21:** the
regeneration now lives inside `wiki-maintain.sh` (step 1/3) in the wiki repo; no standalone
`regenerate-skills-index.sh` exists on disk any more.
3. Set up cron job `1a8e90ea2271` to run daily at 03:00 AWST
4. Script auto-commits and pushes to Gitea (`Anthony/agent-estate-wiki`)
5. Quartz site at `http://100.118.5.51:9120/systems/skills-index` rebuilt and redeployed
## Lesson
Static wiki pages that reflect **mutable inventory** (skills, services, cron jobs) **MUST be auto-regenerated on a schedule**, not hand-maintained. The moment the estate grows, a hand-written page becomes stale.
## Re-verified 2026-10-21
The prevention mechanism is live and working. `wiki-maintain.sh` step 1/3 regenerated
`systems/skills-index.md` from `~/.hermes/skills/` on the 2026-10-21 03:00 scheduled run:
**347 skills across 70 categories** (the "26 categories" figure in the original write-up was
the count at the time of the incident, not the current topology — the skill tree has since
nested deeper). The daily cron job `1a8e90ea2271` is `active` with `last_status: ok`.
## Prevention
- Daily cron job regenerates skills-index.md from live tree
- Page includes "auto-regenerated, do not hand-edit" warning
- Same script pattern is reusable for other inventory pages (cron jobs, services, agents)
## Reopened 2026-10-23 — the count includes archived skills, and two generators disagree
The 2026-10-21 all-clear above was premature. Two defects were confirmed on the
night of 2026-10-22/23:
**1. The stocktake ran six times long and committed nothing.** Cron job
`1a8e90ea2271` ran **03:00:28 → 04:38:19 AWST on 2026-10-22 (97 m 58 s)**, against
**16 m 01 s** on 2026-10-21, and finished `completed` with delivery `suppressed` —
but `git status` in the wiki repo still shows the run's regenerated
`systems/skills-index.md` (mtime 10-22 03:00) **uncommitted**, and none of the fixes
the run had diagnosed were applied. A `completed` row is therefore not evidence that
the stocktake did its job.
**2. Two scripts generate the same page with different shapes.**
| Generator | Skill scan | 2026-10-22 output |
|---|---|---|
| `/home/hermes/workspace/agent-estate-wiki/wiki-maintain.sh` (the one the cron job executes) | `find … -name SKILL.md` — does **not** prune dot-directories | **347** skills, with a `## .Archive (41)` section |
| `/home/hermes/.hermes/scripts/wiki-maintain.sh` (stale copy, mtime 2026-08-17) | `Path.rglob('SKILL.md')` | **348** skills, no archive section |
The 00:18 maintenance step committed the `rglob` shape; the 03:00 stocktake wrote the
`find` shape. Whoever runs last wins, so the page oscillates.
**Live counts, verified 2026-10-23 00:1x AWST** (filesystem probes + `hermes skills list`):
- `find ~/.hermes/skills -name SKILL.md` → **348**
- `find -L ~/.hermes/skills -name SKILL.md` → **376** (28 more skills reachable only through symlinks)
- excluding `.archive/` (**41**) and `apple/` (**4**) → **331**
- the loader's own catalogue — `hermes skills list` → **329 enabled** (`34 hub-installed, 52 builtin, 243 local — 329 enabled, 0 disabled`)
So the page total counts **45 artefacts the loader does not expose** (the parked
`.archive/` set plus `apple/`), which is why its number has never matched the loader.
**Fix applied 2026-10-23:** the repo's `wiki-maintain.sh` now excludes `*/.archive/*`
from the scan, prints the archived count as an explicit exclusion, and states that
`hermes skills list` is the authoritative *loadable* figure while the page remains a
filesystem inventory. The page was regenerated through the patched script and
committed with the fix.
**Still open (as of 2026-10-23):**
- ~~The stale `~/.hermes/scripts/wiki-maintain.sh` copy must never be run — it produces
the divergent shape. It should be deleted or made to delegate to the repo script.~~
**✅ CLOSED 2026-11-05** — the stale copy is now a **delegating wrapper** with no generator logic of its
own; it `exec`s the repo script. The repo script gained `--no-build` so the wrapper can honour the
interface its callers used without carrying a second copy of the generator. Verified by running the
wrapper: it now produces the canonical **302 skills / 68 categories** shape.
→ [[incidents/2026-11-05-skills-index-generator-divergence]]
- The page will still read higher than the loader's 329: nested collections
(`context-engineering-collection/…`), `apple/` and hub-installed trees are counted as
installed files. Whether the page should instead report the loader's figure is a
decision for Anthony.
- Watch the **2026-10-23 03:00** stocktake run: it should complete in ~16 minutes and
commit the regenerated page.
## Related
- [[systems/skills-index]] — The updated page
- [[systems/scheduled-tasks]] — The new cron job