--- title: OmniRoute free-DeepSeek Silent Stops (Empty-After-Tool) — 2026-08-04 type: incident status: monitoring created: 2026-08-04 updated: 2026-11-12 verified_on: 2026-11-12 confidence: high tags: [omniroute, deepseek, free-tier, silent-failure, incident, mitigated] sources: [live-probe, omniroute-log, session-20260804] --- # [2026-08-04] OmniRoute free-DeepSeek silent stops (empty-after-tool) ## Status Mitigated — combos reworked; upstream still degraded. ## Symptom On **both** Hermes instances (ops/Tusk + the other instance), turns using `deepseek-flash-free` (and `smart-route` via `good-free`) did one tool call, then went **silently** — no text, no error. "continue" → one more tool call → silent stop again. ## Root cause The free-DeepSeek upstreams behind the combos started returning **valid-but-empty HTTP 200s right after a tool_calls turn** (no content, no further tool call). Hermes can't distinguish "empty" from "model chose to stop" → ends turn silently. Began **2026-08-01 ~09:14 UTC**, still active. OmniRoute log markers: ``` [STREAM] Empty assistant response after tool_calls completion (:) [ProxyEgress] / ... status=error ``` Per-model evidence (counts in `storage.sqlite` era log): - `238d5978/deepseek-v4-flash` — 63× empty-after-tool (conn `d4b9fee0`, 189 proxy errors) - `238d5978/deepseek-v4-flash-0731` — 70× empty-after-tool - `eb5af0da/deepseek-v4-flash-thinking:free` (conn `f8169018`) — 504 proxy errors (combo #1 slot) - `nvidia` deepseek + `opencode-zen` deepseek-free — noisy, errors Strategy trap: both combos used `priority`, which retries the **same** broken connection and never fails over on an empty 200. ## Change applied (2026-08-04, ~03:30 AWST) Edited `combos` in `/var/lib/omniroute/storage.sqlite` on CT600 (live DB, hot-reloads — no restart): - **`deepseek-flash-free`** — strategy `priority` → `fill-first`; 8 → 7 models: healthy free first (`mimo-v2.5-free`, `laguna-s-2.1:free` ×2 providers, `step-3.7-flash`, `glm-5.2-cheap:free`), one deepseek (`deepseek-v4-flash-thinking:free`) demoted to last resort. - **`good-free`** — strategy `priority` → `fill-first`; 15 → 12 models. **Dropped** the proven culprits: `238d5978/deepseek-v4-flash`, `nvidia/deepseek-ai/deepseek-v4-pro`, `nvidia/deepseek-ai/deepseek-v4-flash`. `opencode/deepseek-v4-flash-free` kept as last resort. Backup of both pre-change rows: `/tmp/combo_backup_20260804.json` on the Hermes gateway LXC. ## Verification - Live API (`/v1/combos`) reflects both changes immediately (hot reload). - 2-step tool-call round-trip through `deepseek-flash-free` returns proper final content. - Direct round-trips (stream + non-stream) through the OLD combo were also healthy — the failure needs the degraded upstream + real session, hence counts not repro. ## Follow-ups - Upstream free-DeepSeek tier still degraded; re-check counts in a few days and restore deepseek-first ordering if it recovers. - Consider `auto`+explorationRate for self-tuning if free tier stays flaky. - Hermes-side: empty-post-tool turns are nudge/retry/fallback handled, but still end silently once exhausted — possible future improvement: surface "(empty after tool calls)" more visibly. ## Re-verified 2026-11-12 03:4x AWST (stocktake — page was 19d old, inside the staleness window) Both reworked combos probed live on **`omniroute-1`** (`100.78.63.20:20128`, `custom:omni-101`) with the correct `key_env` (`HERMES_CUSTOM_100_78_63_20_20128_API_KEY`) and the exact aliases used: | Probe | Result | |---|---| | `good-free` (the 12-model rework) | **HTTP 200**, resolving to **`glm-5.2-cheap:free`** with a valid non-empty completion | | `free-stack` | **HTTP 200**, resolving to **`stepfun-ai/step-5-preview`** with a valid completion | **The mitigation is holding, and the 2026-08-04 follow-up can be partially closed:** both combos answer with real content, and **neither resolves to a deepseek model** — which is exactly the intent of dropping the proven culprits from `good-free`. ⚠ **What is *not* re-verified:** I did not individually probe the free-DeepSeek upstreams (`238d5978/deepseek-v4-flash`, `nvidia/deepseek-ai/deepseek-v4-pro`, `deepseek-v4-flash-thinking:free`), so the original claim *"upstream free-DeepSeek tier still degraded"* stands **neither confirmed nor refuted** — the combos serve healthy non-deepseek free models, which may mean the upstream recovered *or* simply that it is no longer reached. **Restoring deepseek-first ordering is therefore still not justified** and should wait on a direct probe of those three upstreams. ## Refs - [[systems/omniroute]]